We are the "educated elite" they won't listen to

Why did Trump win the 2016 presidential election? Since November 9, many people have been asking the same question. Some say it was because Clinton wasn’t likable enough. Others blame the fact that we didn’t understand the white working class and we believed too many fake news and conspiracy theories.

Yes, those are just some of the answers. There are many more, of course, and political scientists and historians will debate this election for decades to come. But I’ve reached a point where I’ve had enough of reading how everyone else is feeling about this election. I need to say how I feel about it. Because I’m not the white working class woman who lost her job, I’m not Muslim, I’m not Mexican, and yes, I’m an immigrant but the privileged kind if you will. I’ve always been legal and now I am, in fact, a citizen.

I am the educated elite to whom it’s ok to say, “Your college degree doesn’t make you smarter.” The one who tries to counter-argue using scientific sources, real numbers, and logic, and yet all she gets back in response is name-calling and ridicule.

And if you are reading this blog, I know you are part of that same group of people who strive to educate themselves and improve their knowledge, the group of people now clumped under the umbrella term of “educated elite.” So you know exactly what it feels like to be in a strange society where beliefs overcome centuries of scientific and ideological progress. It feels like the doctor who’s been telling his patients to go on a diet and quit eating junk food. We all want to be healthy and fit, yet when it boils down to making the effort, many shrug off the scientific evidence that bad eating habits and no exercise harm our health. We’re all gonna die anyway, right?

No, a college degree doesn’t make anyone smarter. Critical thinking does. And while for many things a college degree is not even needed, there are others—like health, science, and the environment for example—for which those extra years of education provide perspective and deeper understanding of those fields in particular. So when a person with a college degree or equivalent experience tells us something about the field they’ve studied, I think we should listen. What kind of society have we become when we no longer trust scientists when they tell us that greenhouse gases are causing the ocean temperatures to rise? Or when we no longer listen to our doctors when they say that a vaccine can save our children’s life?

There was a time when education was revered and school teachers were respected. A time when people listened to educators and doctors because they had spent decades studying and gaining their knowledge. A time when scientists were heroes because they got us to the moon and physicians saved lives with vaccines. Today, I tell my kids to study because otherwise they’ll never get a good job, and what do they reply? “Mom, Mark Zuckerberg and Bill Gates dropped out of college.” Or, even better: “Mom, YouTubers make millions of dollars and they never have to go to college.”

The Internet has it all. Because anyone can contribute to the Internet, it has all the answers your doctor will never give you, all the science your religion allows you to believe, and a perfect world that beautifully matches your so called values. Why bother with education? Evolution isn’t real, it’s just a theory. We don’t need educated people telling us how old the earth is. We don’t need educated people injecting stuff in our kids’ arms claiming it’ll save their lives. We don’t need educated people telling us that the climate is changing—it’s been changing all throughout the 6,000 years the earth has been around.

Just so we’re clear, what I did in those last three sentences is called sarcasm. Because I did go to school, for many years, in fact. I went to college and then to graduate school. I got my PhD while I was raising two young children. I worked my ass off, I suffered through many failures, I received many rejection letters and yet I kept plowing along, learning from my mistakes, working through the adversities. No, you don’t need a college degree to achieve that. Any kind of hard work makes people stronger. Learning from our mistakes and taking responsibilities makes us grow. And it teaches to respect one other.

But no, America doesn’t need any of that. America keeps binging on junk food and relying on whatever the Internet has to offer. So now teachers are indoctrinating our kids, scientists are conspiracy theorists who enjoy telling us that the world will end, and doctors are vaccine impostors paid by the Big Pharma. (On a side note, vaccines are cheap, they don’t make the Big Pharma rich. What makes them rich are all the drugs you need when you get the diseases you could’ve vaccinated against.)

Who needs educated people when we can do stuff on our own? This, you see, has been this election’s winning message. And that’s exactly why the incoming cabinet features a secretary of education who wants to dismantle public education; a national security adviser who tweets fake news; a secretary of treasury who ran a bank that was dubbed the “foreclosure machine”; an EPA administrator who doesn’t believe in environmental policies and doesn’t believe in climate change. If you think about it, it’s like all these people, instead of being rightfully shamed for their failures, have been rewarded with the highest positions in the government. All because we no longer trust education, let alone if it comes from the establishment. Can you hear your teenage kid’s voice? “Get out of the way, Mom. I can do stuff on my own, now!”

Truth is, the secretary of energy for the past two terms has been a PhD. In fact, our previous secretary of energy was a Nobel laureate. These bright minds will now be succeeded by a BS in animal science and Dancing with the Stars contestant. I’m sure those stardom experiences will come in handy when talking to scientists and engineers about the state of our nuclear weapons and climate change policies. Oh wait. I forgot, the guy doesn’t believe in climate change. So I’m sure he doesn’t believe in investing money in basic research to address questions like, “Why are our trees dying?” or “Is there going to be enough water for our growing cities twenty years from now?” or “How are we going to sustain our agriculture when we’ll run out of water?” or “Can we make more potent antibiotics in order to fight drug resistant bacteria?”

And if you are wondering, all those questions do pertain the US Department of Energy. DOE oversees national security labs like the one where I work. My colleagues and I work hard everyday on questions like the ones I mentioned above because drug-resistant bacteria and water problems are among the greatest threats our society is facing today. Ill-minded people can easily get a hold of these problems and turn them into bioweapons. But don’t worry, I’m sure the Internet holds all the answers.

Nelson Mandela once said, “Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world.” I want you to think about that for a moment. What do Mandela’s words say about a country where college education is so expensive that many can no longer afford it? And even worse, a country where a good chunk of the population does not trust college education? Knowledge is freedom. Ignorance, instead, is the shackles used by tyrannic powers.

And so America gulps down another mouthful of fat hamburger with fries, washed down with corn syrup based soda. Because no matter how many times we tell America to go on a diet (i.e. invest in renewable energy), no matter how many times we lecture America about the risks of high blood pressure (i.e. stop fracking and drilling before all of our drinking water ends up contaminated), and no matter how many times we remind America that the number one cause of death in the US is heart failure (i.e. temperatures are indeed rising and we’re all going to die if we don’t do something about it), America has decided that we are the educated elite and no longer deserve to be listened to.

So good luck America. In a world too busy to take the time to ponder, too loud to stop to listen, and too arrogant to realize its own ignorance, the educated elite is all you’ll have left when catastrophe will strike. And in the best of Hollywood traditions, we will be there to come to the rescue.

Until then, God help us all.

Thank you to Kat Fieler and Mike Martin for helpful suggestions while editing this post. All opinions expressed here are mine and mine alone. I respect yours, please respect mine. 


Stay In Touch - Join My Newsletter

  Sign Up Now  

My Books

About E.E. Giorgi

2 Responses to We are the "educated elite" they won't listen to

  1. Profile Cover Art

    I find your posts to be thoughtful, educational and enlightening – all things that I hold dear. Now that I am better able think (thank you, chemo, you saved me!) I hope to spend more time reading blogs – for while my reading of(fiction) books is often enlightening I have never lost my love of considerations about this World we Live in. (I actually investigate the subjects that are written about in the books I read, even fiction.)

    About your post – I am also educated through college, although not to the degree you are, and had not thought about things the way you’ve expressed them herein before. I worked very hard for my grades in school, as does everyone who intends to learn from their college experiences. It wasn’t easy to get A’s and B’s, sometimes even getting a C was difficult. I am also self-taught, as so many are today, and perhaps that is why I did not think in terms of having been to college(s) this way, but I imagine it is more along the lines that you are you & I am myself, and your mind is made to think more globally than I have been able to of late. While I think in terms of what society may be headed towards, socially as well as morally or spiritually, and psychologically, you think in terms of science.

    To this I say – Thank goodness for the scientists of the World. I applaud you for having been so conscienceable as to go into your chosen field. The world is fortunate to have people like you – people who know many of the main-stream bits of humanity are not as Aware of what all it takes to keep this planet clean & running (we tend to sort of just think – as a whole – it just ‘takes care of itself’, which is why it is now so very polluted! It Would take care of itself, except we keep trashing our planet!), and are willing to come pick up the pieces when the rest of the world gets done muddying things up.

    And… I apologize, I am sorry… that it is that way. That more people don’t THINK before they act on their feelings or desires. I am sorry that intelligent people who lean towards the studies that require more Science are the ones left to clean up the muck of the rest of humanity – both the educated and non-educated. I wish… people would think before they act more often, but since that isn’t likely to change anytime soon, I wish – at least – people would stop insisting on plowing onward along paths that are shown not to work. Ego gets in the way, pure and simple. Ego – people have a very hard time admitting they may have made a mistake. Even I do, and I am consciously aware of this flaw in our make-up. Because I tend to think for a long while before I act I sometimes have a difficult time believing I may have acted impulsively or may not have thought about all the possibilities of my actions. Like most people, I do not like to BE wrong. But… I do tend to be more willing than most people I know in admitting it when I see I have been… Often, people who claim others should admit their mistakes won’t do so themselves, but that is not the case with me. While it is hurtful, even gives me stomach cramps to admit publicly when I have made choices or decisions then actions that have results that are not what I supposed they would be, I do it anyway. I guess what my father told me from the time I was a wee baby hold true even today – “It takes all kinds to make this world go ’round.” I suppose – what I really wish is that humanity would embrace the possibility that there is a whole WORLD of possibilities to every thing, and be more open minded that what you, or I, or their neighbor thinks may not be wrong. Oh, and stop mucking up our Planet!

    • Profile Cover Art

      I see I didn’t say that very well. I did not mean to imply you do not also think in terms of morality, spiritual things, or psychological things – I *should* have stated – I do not think in scientific terms as well as you do, and that perhaps – few are able to.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *